Skip to content
Sonalyze

Insurers: qualifying a noise claim before the expert assessment

Sonalyze · 18 November 2026 · reading time : 3 min

A noise claim arrives as a story. The claims handler has to decide whether an expert assessment is needed, which one and against whom, without being able to hear what the policyholder is talking about.

Three types of claims

  • Neighbours: behaviour or an activity, handled under legal protection.
  • Construction: an insulation defect in a new home.
  • Equipment: lift, ventilation, boiler room, heat pump.

What French construction law provides

The seller of a new home is liable to the first occupant, for one year from taking possession, for compliance with sound insulation requirements.

Beyond that, the Cour de cassation (France's highest court) ruled on 21 September 2011 that a sound insulation defect can fall under the ten-year guarantee if it makes the building unfit for its purpose, even when the minimum regulatory requirements are met.

Why sorting claims is difficult

  • The nuisance described does not say whether the noise comes from behaviour, equipment or the structure.
  • The noise may be absent on the day the expert visits.
  • The choice of assessment depends on the cause, which is not yet known.

What a preliminary measurement brings

  • A box sent to the policyholder, set up in a few minutes.
  • From 24 hours to 1 week of measurement, by day and by night.
  • The times and type of noise, to direct the claim to the right guarantee.
  • A report a claims handler can read without acoustic expertise.

What it does not do

It does not replace the expert assessment and does not decide liability. The boxes are not certified sound level meters: checking a building's compliance requires standardised measurements, carried out by an acoustician.

Sources

This guide gives general information about the situation in France and does not replace legal or technical advice suited to your situation.

Read also